Pawlicity will be closed from Friday, September 22 (3:00PM ET) to Monday, October 9, 2017 (9:00AM ET). Any order placed during this time will begin shipping in the order received on October 9, 2017. Thank you for your patience and patronage.

FREE SHIPPING with orders of $60.00 or more

Plush Playthings

Display: List / Grid
Show:
Sort By:
  Floppy, flat and fabulous, the stuffing-free Floppy Dog dog toy is designed for dogs t..
$7.00
  Floppy, flat and fabulous, the stuffing-free Floppy Quack dog toy is designed for dogs..
$7.00
  Floppy, flat and fabulous, the stuffing-free Floppy Giraffe dog toy is designed for do..
$7.00
Beginnings 4" plush Lolly Lamb comes in pink and white with a squeaker in his belly. These c..
$7.99
This is Gary the Alligator from Simply Fido toys! The plush green fleece on Gary will make h..
$16.00
Meet Leo the Lion from Simply Fido toys!    Leo is a happy lion covered in a pl..
$16.00
Meet Leo the Lion from Simply Fido toys!  Leo is a happy lion covered in a plush fleece!..
$12.00
Meet Leo the Lion from Simply Fido toys!    Leo is a lion covered in soft organ..
$12.00
Meet Lolly the Lamb from Simply Fido toys!    Lolly is a happy lamb covered in ..
$16.00
Meet Lolly the Lamb from Simply Fido toys!    Lolly is a happy lamb covered in ..
$12.00
Meet Lucy the Bunny from Simply Fido toys!    Lucy is a yellow plush bunny with..
$16.00
Let's all welcome Maggie the Caterpillar from Simply Fido toys!    Maggie's mul..
$16.00
Meet Oscar the Monkey from Simply Fido toys!    Oscar is a light brown monkey w..
$12.00
This is Wally Blue Bear from Simply Fido toys! The plush blue fabric on Wally will make him ..
$12.00
Is your puppy lonely and in need of a brother or sister?  Best Bud Dog will fit the bill wit..
$18.49 $12.99
    Every dog loves a bone, but you will love this plush dog toy even more sinc..
From $9.49
West Paw has put a crinkly, twist on a holiday favorite. Handcrafted in the USA, these Crinkle Ca..
$15.49
  Go ahead and let your dog play some reindeer games, these reindeer dog toys can take i..
From $11.49
Patches Monkey  has a refreshing mint color perfect for when the weather gets warmer.  ..
$18.49 $13.49
Patchwork Pal Bunny has a soft yet durable body stuffed with crunchy filling to entertain your do..
$18.49 $12.99
Patchwork Pal Lamb has a soft yet durable body stuffed with crunchy filling to entertain your dog..
$18.49 $12.99
Our Pond Hopper Frog 14" has a soft, textured body that contains 1 grunter and 2 squeakers to sur..
$15.99 $11.49
Our Pond Hopper Frog 14" has a soft, textured body that contains 1 grunter and 2 squeakers to sur..
$15.99 $11.49
Durable yet textured and soft, Pond Hopper Lizard 14" will give your dog lasting fun with 2 squea..
$15.99 $11.49
  If you go into the woods today will you find a Teddy Bear's picnic? Start one of your ..
$4.99
This special edition Snowman Buddy is soft and sweet with a jolly ol' squeak inside. He is 9" of ..
$9.95 $8.49
Children aren’t the only ones who need a teddy bear! Soft corduroy fabric and recycled polyfill c..
$13.49
Though it’s tiny, this Tiny Turtle small dog toy is a big hit with the little dogs! Made especial..
$4.99
This fearless lion features a one-piece seamless body, making him more tear resistant when tugged..
$18.49 $14.99
  West Paw's Turtle dog toy is no ordinary turtle - this turtle is helping the environme..
$12.49